C O M M E N T S
From: "Matti Salminen" <matti.salminen@ppe.inet.fi>
Date: Mon, 09 Apr 2001 16:05:16 GMT
Hot Rats - Authentic Trascriptions
This is a BRAND NEW BOOK with Authentic Transcriptions with Notes and
Tablature for HOT RATS!! This is #1 of a soon to be a huge collection. Songs
from the book include, Peaches en Regalia, Willie the Pimp, Son of Mr. Green
Genes, Little Umbrellas, The Gumbo Variations and It Must Be A Camel. There
is a introduction by Matt Groening.
COMING SOON
From: Doug Boucher
...
but I'm so happy they did anything at all that
I
won't bother complaining too much. I DO wish they'd done more with Little
Umbrellas, particularly the "keyboard ensemble solo" section that they
merely give basic chords to. But damn, it sure is nice that there's
something out there, eh?
From: Craig Jones
From memory, Andy Aledort told me that it was done that way because he
percieved that the keyboard section was not a "written" part that FZ would
have wanted played that way, but a keyboard improvisation.(Apologies to Andy
if this is not exactly what he said)
From: Andy Aledort <aaledort@ix.netcom.com>
Date: Mon, 23 Apr 2001 08:10:00 -0400
I did the "Hot Rats" book, and as Craig says in his post, the "keyboard
ensemble part" was transcribed that way because I believe it was improvised
and not written. Of course, major sections of three-part horn arrangements
are transcribed in the book (arranged for guitar, no less) so I think the
complaining should be kept to a minimum. It would have been nice to have
been furnished with charts, soloed-out tracks, etc., but alas it had to be
done by ear. And obviously it's pretty silly to complain that the keyboard
ensemble part is not transcribed, and then imply that it's a waste of paper
to transcribe the guitar solos in their entirety because someone is not
interested in learning them note-for-note. That is not really the point, as
we all know. By the way, I get paid more than $25 a page to transcribe
books--that fee just covers single guitar or bass parts for instruction
purposes, not whole arrangements, and what gets transcribed and how is up to
my discretion.
Anyhow, I've always loved the "Hot Rats" album, and I'm glad it's finally
transcribed! I am currently working on "Apostrophe." If anyone has
questions, you can email me directly at:aaledort@ix.netcom.com
|
|